Safe Third Country Agreement with Canada

The Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA) between Canada and the United States has been a topic of controversy and interest for years. The agreement, which was first signed in 2002, stipulates that people seeking asylum must make their claim in the country where they first arrived. The agreement is aimed at reducing the number of refugees who “shop” around for a country that will be most advantageous to their case.

However, opponents of the agreement argue that it puts refugees in danger by forcing them to seek asylum in the United States, where they may be subjected to discrimination and harsh treatment. They also claim that the United States is not a “safe” third country for refugees, as it has been accused of violating international law and human rights abuses.

In July 2020, a court decision challenged the STCA and declared it unconstitutional, citing that the United States was not a safe country for refugees. The Canadian government was given six months to respond to the ruling, during which time the STCA remains in effect.

The STCA has received a lot of attention during the COVID-19 pandemic, as the United States has implemented more stringent immigration policies and travel restrictions. Some experts believe that the pandemic has further exposed the flaws in the STCA and the need for Canada to reconsider its refugee policy.

While some argue that the STCA is necessary to maintain control over the refugee system and prevent “asylum shopping,” others argue that it puts refugees in harm’s way and that Canada should look to alternative solutions. One alternative suggested is a “complementary protection” approach, where Canada would assess each refugee claim on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the individual’s circumstances and whether they would be at risk in the United States.

Regardless of the eventual outcome, the STCA continues to be a topic of debate and discussion in Canada. As the country grapples with immigration policy and the ongoing global refugee crisis, it will be interesting to see how this agreement evolves and what alternatives are proposed.

Safe Third Country Agreement with Canada
Scroll hacia arriba